?
Feedback

Connecting Sociology and YOU!

Diagnosis

  1. Although there are limited examples of violence against women by healthcare workers in the U.S., it does exist. Can you recall examples that you have read or heard about?
  2. Specifically, how does the healthcare system and regulatory agencies protect women from violence?
  3. As a healthcare worker, how can you prevent violence against women within your professional setting and the larger society?

Violence Against Women

As alarming and disturbing as it may sound, there are women who experience neglect and verbal, physical, and sexual violence by health care workers. Most of these incidents are in developing countries that do not have the same quality of care standards and oversight by regulatory agencies. The following are examples related to childbirth.

Verbal Violence

This type of violence includes unkind, rude, brusque, unsympathetic, and uncaring treatment and being shouted at and scolded during labor and delivery. Nigerian women have been forced to clean their room after delivery as a form of punishment.

Neglect

In South Africa, there are documented cases of women giving birth unattended by a health professional within hospitals due to midwives and nurses watching TV, sleeping, or talking among themselves and did not want to be bothered. Women, who arrived at the clinic or hospital in labor and without an appointment, were told to wait until all others were attended to, as a form of punishment for not going through the proper prenatal educational programming that would have afforded them an appointment.

Physical Violence

In Peru, there are reports of midwives who often slap or hit women while giving birth if they are noncompliant when asked to push. There are examples of deliberate refusal to give anesthetics or analgesics as a form of punishment and to teach the mother a lesson.

Sexual Violence

There are documented cases of rape in Pakistan hospitals but patients are reluctant to report the violence due to fear of reprisals.

In general, societies that have a culture and acceptance of violence may extend to a small degree the acceptance of the four types of violence in specific circumstances to healthcare workers.