Notes:
The Intersection of Economics and Politics
Economics and politics intersect within societies at the individual and structural levels in many ways, including campaign financing, special interest groups, and the concentration of wealth among politicians. Sociologists also examine women’s and minorities’ political participation, the relationship between power and politics, and how politics shape public policy. This broad field of study is called political sociology, the study of political groups, leadership, and social power. One example is the democratic socialist movement resulting from Vermont Senator Bernie Sander’s bid to win the Democratic presidential nomination in 2016 and 2020. His campaign platform included healthcare for all, making tuition free at public colleges and universities, a $15 minimum wage, and enacting a universal childcare and prekindergarten program (Bernie 2019). Sanders believes the issue of wealth and income inequality is the greatest moral, economic, and political issue of our time. He contends that since the mid-1980s, there has been an enormous wealth transfer from the middle class and the poor to the top one-tenth of 1 percent of America’s wealthiest individuals. His website states, “We will no longer accept 46 percent of all new income going to the top 1 percent, while millions of Americans are forced to work two or three jobs just to survive and over half of our people live paycheck to paycheck.” Early sociologists, like Karl Marx (1818–1883), wrote about the power imbalance among groups in society. They believed political systems are grounded within particular economic systems, an idea which will be addressed in the next module (Marx 1976). Max Weber (1864–1920) shed light on authority, power, and leadership (Weber 1972), while contemporary sociologist Pierre Bourdieu (1930–2002) focused on the relations between language, power, and politics (Bourdieu 1993). Each of these sociologists recognized the inseparable connections between economics and politics, and in this section, we will use the sociological perspective to explore this connection.
The Economics of Political Participation
Since you are approximately three-quarters of the way through SociologicalYOU, you know that most of our social behaviors result from socialization and specific social factors. Socioeconomic status (SES) predetermines many of our “choices” in life. The word “choices” is in quotation marks because, although we have the freedom to make our own decisions about how we conduct our social lives, many of our decisions are heavily influenced by our personal and family income, educational attainment, occupational status, and geography. In addition to SES, political involvement predictors include your participation in voluntary organizations in high school and your social media habits. You could predict each of your classmates’ level of political engagement, to some degree of accuracy, by determining SES, involvement in school clubs and organizations, and social media habits.
There are three basic categories of political involvement: political participation, civic participation, and political consumerism. The first category, political participation, actions to support the government or politicians (HP), includes voting, wearing a badge to support a candidate, and being a member of a political party. If you have exercised your right to vote, you have engaged in political participation (C-19). Have you involved yourself in the Young Democrats, Young Republicans, or other campus political organizations? How has your socialization process contributed to your involvement or lack of involvement? If you engage in civic participation, individual and collective action to address issues of public concern, this is a more specific and targeted involvement that includes donating to a candidate, volunteering to collect signatures, and engaging in rallies and protests. Charles Koch and, before his death, his brother David have been actively engaged in civic participation. They have donated to candidates to address their personal concerns, which they believe are also important public concerns. A third category is political consumerism, choosing producers and products with the goal of changing ethical or objectionable institutional or market practices, which is when you boycott or “buycott” a product based on moral and ethical reasons. Consumers can practice citizenship and become important political actors by pressuring corporations to change their business practices. You may have chosen not to purchase items from clothing and footwear companies due to their use of child labor in other countries or refused to gas up your automobile at specific gas stations due to environmental practices and disasters and human rights policies of the multinational petroleum corporations.
The Civic Voluntarism Model
Who is most likely to be politically engaged? Using the sociological perspective, you can analyze why individuals and groups get involved in politics. Economics, specifically SES, is one of the strongest predictors of whether individuals are involved in politics. Children who grow up in upper-middle-class and upper-class families are more likely to have politically engaged parents. Verba, Schlozman, and Burns (2005) characterize these parents as more likely to
- have high levels of political knowledge, interest, efficacy, and tolerance
- engage in political discussion
- be politically active
- encourage their children to become independent and to express themselves fully in family discussions
The children of these parents are having political discussions in the home and have the means to pursue higher education, which also presents opportunities to engage in political conversations. The Civic Voluntarism model (HP) supports that SES is a strong indicator (Verba, Schlozman, and Brady 1995). This model indicates that individuals civically volunteer based on three factors: resources, motivation, and location within recruitment networks. In other words, those who are able to, want to, and are asked to take part are more likely to be politically involved. Each of these factors is more conducive to upper-income families. Did your family have the economic means to participate by donating to political campaigns, taking time off work to participate in political rallies, or purchasing alternative products or services as a means of protest? Were you exposed to high levels of political discussion in your home? Were important political issues and current events discussed around the dinner table? Were you directly or indirectly taught how politics relate to your everyday life? These family behaviors all increase political engagement (Huckfeldt and Sprague 1995). The process continues through higher education as students gain civic skills by participating in non-political organizations and developing social networks. By being in college, you have situated yourself within a social environment that will provide opportunities for being recruited to participate in political activities and organizations.
In addition to SES, your participation in voluntary organizations as a teenager is a strong predictor of your future participation. Ellen Quintelier, a Belgian sociologist, asked, “Who is more politically active: the athlete, the scout member, or the environmental activist?” The answer is the environmental activist, as individuals who participate in sports groups are more homogenous and have more in-group goals. A teenager interested in environmentalism is more individualistic and focused on out-group goals (Quintelier 2008).
The Scouts of America (formerly Boy Scouts of America or BSA) are homogenous and more outwardly focused than athletes but less so than environmentalists. Individuals with a higher SES have more resources to focus on out-groups than those with fewer resources, thus a greater likelihood of political participation. Quintelier’s study also found the more voluntary organizations a student joins in high school, the more predictive of increased political participation in adulthood. This is most likely due to gaining more civic skills and resources, which fits the Civic Voluntarism Model. Once in college, students involved in political activism continue their participation throughout their lifetime. Fendrich and Lavoy (1988) conducted a longitudinal study beginning in the 1960s and followed college students engaged in political activism. Over 25 years later, most of these students were still politically engaged. The profile of politically engaged individuals is depicted

Political Participation and Social Media
The last component of the political engagement profile is related to social media. Research shows that more Americans are using social media to engage in civic and political participation (Jones 2019; Yang and DeHart 2016; Wang 2013; Rainie et al. 2012). Engagement in social media provides an easily accessible means for users to connect with politicians, stay up to date with the latest political news, and support political platforms and current issues. Have you used social media for any of these purposes? The downside to social media is the potential to fall prey to fake news, conspiracy theories, and confirmation bias. Those more connected to social media are also more politically engaged, but we can’t definitively say there is a correlation between the two and state that social media causes political engagement.
The younger generations are more likely to get their news from social media, which is more diverse than news gathered by the older generations from legacy media (i.e., local, national, and cable television). Viewers of legacy media are more likely to choose a television source providing news from primarily one political party. Social media allows younger voters to be exposed to various political sources resulting in the decentralization of information and exposure to a greater diversity of opinions compared to older cohorts relying primarily on legacy media. Although, the ability to choose hyper-personalized social media news feeds can result in participating in an echo chamber, thus limiting exposure to a wide array of opinions. Therefore, how individuals curate political information via media will likely impact their political views and engagement (Foster and Markiewicz 2023). Even though access to the internet and social media is relatively available to all SES levels, there is still a significant socioeconomic distinction regarding education and income. Americans with bachelor’s and graduate degrees and higher household incomes are more likely to be politically engaged online and offline. The gap between lower and higher SES is significantly wider in the following areas:
- attending a political rally or speech
- working or volunteering for a political party or candidate
- contacting an official about an issue that is important to you, either offline or online
- donating to a political candidate
Have you engaged in any of these four activities? The most important question is why you have or have not been politically active. One answer is, “I am just not interested in politics.” Another response might be, “My vote or contributions will not matter.” Both statements may have some truth, but when you apply the sociological perspective, your family’s socioeconomic status has influenced your attitudes about political engagement. If your family did not discuss politics and you did not observe your parents attending a political rally or volunteering for a political candidate, then you are more likely to say, “I am not interested in politics.” This is an example of how sociology can provide insight into your beliefs and whether you engage in political activities.
A survey by the Pew Research Internet Project revealed that 39 percent of adults in America used social media in the 2012 elections to engage in one of these eight categories:
- 38 percent used social media to “like” or promote political content others posted
- 35 percent used social media to encourage others to vote
- 34 percent used social media to post comments on political issues
- 33 percent used social media to repost political content
- 31 percent used social media to engage in political activities
- 28 percent used social media to post links to political content for others to read
- 20 percent used social media to follow political candidates
(Rainie et al. 2012)
Although these seven categories indicate political participation based on the Pew study, it can be argued that social media facilitates political expression more than participation (Zuniga, Molyneux, and Zheng 2014). Take a moment to reread the seven categories and determine how many appear more expressive than participatory. Most of the categories pertain to consuming or redistributing information rather than directly supporting politicians. The Pew study found that only 18 percent of the respondents engaged in some political activity after reading about it online. Next, we will turn our attention to women and politics.
Women and Politics
There are fewer women than men in politics. The reasons behind the lopsided numbers are discoverable by using the sociological perspective. You arrived at your current level of political engagement due to social factors such as SES and some of your aptitudes and interests in politics. In much the same way, socialization patterns are impacting young women’s political ambitions.
Ilhan Omar (see photo) has been the U.S. Representative for Minnesota’s 5th Congressional District since 2019. She was outspoken as a freshman Congresswoman and was denied an official visit to Israel in August 2019 due to previously calling for and working to impose boycotts on Israel. What do you think her political socialization patterns were that encouraged her to seek office? Why are there significantly fewer women in Congress and the highest cabinet positions?
Political Socialization
Political socialization begins in the family and continues through school and into the workforce. Are boys and girls treated the same regarding political ambitions within the family? Lawless and Fox (2013) identify five factors that hinder young women’s political ambition. The first three obstacles result from a combination of family, peers, school, and media, all of which are agents of socialization:
- Young men are more likely to be socialized than young women to pursue a career in politics.
- Young women are exposed to less political information at school, among peers, and within the media.
- Young men are more likely to play sports, which develops a competitive nature and desire to win.
These agents of socialization view political ambition more favorably among boys and have a powerful impact on whether a girl daydreams about becoming a politician. If girls express interest in pursuing a political career, there may be pushback from parents, friends, and teachers.
In 2022, 27.1 percent of the U.S. Congress were women (Center for American Women and Politics 2022). The U.S. ranks 70th out of 187 countries regarding the number of women in national parliaments (Inter-Parliamentary Union 2022).
The last two hindrances pertain to how women are encouraged to run or not to run for public office once they are older:
- Young women are less likely to receive encouragement from anyone to run for public office.
- Young women think they are less qualified to run for public office even when established in their careers.
This may help explain why women hold only a quarter of the seats in Congress. Figure 11.1.2 describes the representation of women in the 117th Congress. Notice there were significantly more Democratic than Republican Congresswomen.

One of the exciting aspects of sociology and other social sciences research is that it helps inform public policy and political strategies. Information provided by the report Girls Just Wanna Not Run: The Gender Gap in Young Americans’ Political Ambition is valuable in developing political strategies to increase the number of women in politics in the U.S. The political action committee (PAC) titled Emily’s List has been recruiting and training women candidates since 1984, the year Geraldine Ferraro ran for Vice President (Hunt 2014). This Democratic PAC trains 1,000 women to run for governor’s offices and Congressional seats. This PAC has created a network of donors to level the playing field so these women are not disadvantaged regarding fundraising. Republicans do not have an equivalent PAC, and the number of women GOP candidates lags far behind the Democrats. Although in 2023, there were four Republican and eight Democratic women governors, 18 states have never had a woman governor (CAWP 2023). In 2022, Governors Maura Healey (D-MA) and Tina Kotek (D-OR) became the first openly-lesbian women to serve as governors. No Black, Middle Eastern/North African, or Native American/Alaska Native/Native Hawaiian women have ever served as governor. Two Hispanic women and one Asian American woman have been elected as governor (Dittmar 2022).
In interviews of current and former women U.S. governors and gubernatorial candidates, it was found that women emerge as candidates due to the socio-political culture within the state (Windett 2014). If states have a historical pattern of electing women to lower levels of office, then the state will have a larger number of qualified candidates. States with lower numbers of women participating in public office are more likely to have fewer candidates. These patterns can create structural impediments for women gubernatorial candidates. Governor Mary Fallin was elected Governor of Oklahoma in 2010, reelected in 2014, and served until 2019. She was the first woman governor of the state. What questions would you ask Governor Fallin about the socio-political culture of Oklahoma?
Women in Politics Around the Globe
Each year Rwanda celebrates its Liberation Day on July 4. This marks the end of the genocide that killed more than 800,000 people in 1994 and the beginning of a new government on July 4 of the same year. One aspect of the new constitution is that 30 percent of political and government candidates must be women (Dudman 2014). Worldwide, women only represent 26 percent of the seats in parliaments (Table 11.1.1). Before the Rwandan civil war and genocide, few women were in politics. Over the past two decades, there has been a sweeping cultural shift in Rwanda’s gender roles. This social change is largely attributed to Swanee Hunt, a former Harvard professor, philanthropist, and activist for women’s inclusion in governments (1972 TCU alumnus). After the 1994 genocide in Rwanda, she developed programs to involve women in politics and government. These programs provided opportunities for women to participate in parliament resulting in empowerment, equality, and justice for Rwandan women (UN Women Staff 2018). Rwanda has the most women in parliament (61 percent) compared to 27 percent in the U.S., which puts the U.S. in the 87th position among 192 countries (Inter-Parliamentary Union 2022). This can be partly explained by how the socialization process occurs in different countries worldwide.
| Region | Percent of Women in Parliament May 1, 2022 |
|---|---|
| The Middle East and North Africa | 16.5% |
| Pacific | 20.9% |
| Asia | 20.7% |
| Sub-Sarahan Africa | 26.0% |
| Europe | 31.1% |
| The Americas | 34.6% |
| World Average | 26.0% |
All of these statistics and information about women in politics in the U.S. and around the world can help you think about the social processes behind the data. Consider that Saudi Arabia allowed women over 21 to travel abroad without a male guardian’s permission, divorcees and widows to be head of a household, and all Saudis to be considered “equal in the right to work” regardless of sex, handicap, age or other criteria (Bulos 2019). The previous cultural norms, and only allowing women to begin driving in 2018, partially explain why Saudi Arabia is ranked 117th regarding the number of women in parliament. As women gain new freedoms and rights within Saudi Arabia, it is predictable that women’s political participation will also increase.
Economics, Politics, and Climate Change
This section will apply the sociological perspective to the link between politics and climate change. The topic of climate change (HP) has been debated for decades. On one side, individuals and groups claim that humans cause rising temperatures and erratic weather patterns; on the other side, they believe climate change revolves around the naturally occurring cycles of rising and lowering temperatures over tens of thousands of years. Our goal is not to convince you to choose a side but to apply the sociological perspective to the topic in relation to economics and politics. Remember that attempting to remain neutral and unbiased is crucial when practicing sociology. Figure 11.1.3 shows the opinion of Americans on the cause of global warming between 2008 and 2018. As an update, the percentages (not reflected in the figure below) have changed from 62 to 61 percent and from 23 to 28 in 2023 (Ipsos 2023). The daily news reflects record-breaking weather events and disruptions in the lives of people around the world, but yet the percentage of Americans who think global warming is mostly caused by natural changes in the environment has only slightly decreased since 2008. Why do you think 28 percent of Americans do not think global warming is caused mostly by human activities?
A discussion of climate change must begin with Al Gore’s 2006 documentary film, An Inconvenient Truth, and its 2017 follow-up, An Inconvenient Sequel: Truth to Power. Al Gore served as Vice President within the Bill Clinton presidential administration from 1993 to 2001. The film compellingly introduced the concept of global warming to the American public. He skillfully presented the topic using his life story, statistics, charts and graphs, and predictions about our planet’s future. The former Vice President toured the U.S. and worldwide, screening the documentary and discussing the topic. He trained hundreds of individuals to do the same, and they made similar presentations to smaller groups and organizations. Amazingly, he single-handedly raised awareness of global warming from a term unfamiliar to the masses to a common phrase discussed by individuals, households, organizations, and governments globally. Today, Al Gore’s Climate Reality organization is catalyzing a global solution to the climate crisis by making urgent action necessary across every sector of society. The use of polar bears is common to elicit emotional responses and reinforce urgent action.
Another significant event was the 15-year-old Swedish Greta Thunberg’s speech at the 2018 United Nations Climate Change Conference. It rocked the world, resulting in her becoming a world-renown climate activist. She established school strikes on Fridays for climate and has been the voice and spokesperson for young people around the globe (Chang, Ryan, and Intagliata 2023). Her message is straightforward and depicts the urgency of responding to climate change: “If we do not [phase out fossil fuels], it will be a death sentence for countless people. It is already a death sentence for countless people” (Harvey 2023).
Scientists don’t agree about the cause of global warming and the increase in temperatures may be due to the natural cooling and warming patterns that have fluctuated over thousands of years.
This is a myth,
Human influence on the climate system is clear, and recent anthropogenic emissions of greenhouse gases are the highest in history. Recent climate changes have had widespread impacts on human and natural systems.
Al Gore used the term global warming, the rise in surface temperature on the planet, and the term climate change, the weather impacts of the rising temperatures, have been used interchangeably. From a symbolic interaction perspective, the two phrases evoke varying emotions, beliefs, and degrees of urgency to address the issues. Table 11.1.2 summarizes a 2021 Gallup study that found that thoughts regarding whether or not global warming will pose a serious threat in one’s lifetime depend on political affiliation. Eleven percent of Republicans view global warming as a serious threat, compared to 67 percent of Democrats (Saad 2021).
| Group Description | Percent worried about it in 2015 | Percent worried about it in 2016 |
|---|---|---|
| Republicans | 31% | 40% |
| Independents | 55% | 64% |
| Democrats | 78% | 84% |
Although there was an immediate and lasting buzz over global warming, the discussions quickly became politically polarized. From the beginning, many Republicans doubted the science and called global warming a hoax. Although 95 percent of scientists worldwide indicate that human activity has contributed to global warming over the past century, a substantial percentage of Republicans question the science (Milman 2015). A 2021 poll indicated that 39 percent of Republicans viewed climate change as a serious problem facing the U.S., compared to 95 percent of Democrats (Fears and Guskin 2021).
In 2014, Republican Congressman Dan Benishek of Michigan stated, “The climate may be changing, but I don’t think man is contributing to it. I think it’s just the natural course of things. I believe in peer-reviewed science. But, I don’t see any peer-reviewed science that proves there is man-made catastrophic climate change” (Ashtari 2014). In the same year, Democrat California Governor Jerry Brown said, “It is true that there’s virtually no Republican [in Washington] who accepts the science that virtually is unanimous” (Kliegman 2014). This begs the question as to why there is such a split between the parties.
In general, Democrats are more supportive of environmental legislation. In 2015, the Republican-led 115th Congress worked to roll back President Obama’s environmental legislation. The foremost reasons provided by Republicans to vote against more stringent Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) rules and regulations are that a) regulatory costs cripple the economy and b) the skepticism about the cause of climate change (Cama 2014). The economy is the intersection between politics and climate change and where Democrats and Republicans differ on the issue of climate change. Democrats favor government regulations to protect citizens, especially the disadvantaged. Republicans believe that government regulations hinder free-market capitalism and job growth. Legislation to address climate change is generally passed in the form of regulations such as stricter EPA guidelines for improved fuel use for automobiles, carbon pollution standards for new power plants, and oil and natural gas air pollution standards. These examples are considered to restrict free-market capitalism from the Republican perspective, which is a key economic consideration when voting on environmental issues.
Consider the Keystone XL Pipeline, approved by President Trump in 2017, which was a proposed 1,700-mile pipeline capable of delivering 830,000 barrels of oil a day from Canada through the heartland of the U.S. President Biden denied the permit to build the pipeline, and the Canadian company, TC Energy, officially abandoned the project in 2021 (Denchak and Lindwall 2022; Kane and Eilperin 2014).
Environmentalists argued the pipeline would increase the amount of oil extracted from the Canadian tar sands and increase pollution. The potential for oil spills (17,000 gallons of oil was spilled in South Dakota in April 2016) and the threat to endangered species such as the whooping crane, Northern swift fox, and the black-footed ferrets far outweighed the economic benefits (Neuhauser 2016). On the other hand, the Republicans pointed to the 118,000 new jobs that would have raised the standard of living for working men and women in the construction, manufacturing, and transportation industries. Energy security was touted as a major benefit of the pipeline, and the U.S. State Department’s Final Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement released in early 2014 stated the pipeline would not greatly increase carbon emissions. In November of 2014, the Senate failed to pass the legislation to approve the pipeline amongst Lakota Native American chants in protest during the counting of votes in the Senate chambers. Native Americans have protested the pipeline going through their sacred grounds, and some tribes have publicly stated that building the pipeline would constitute an “act of war” (Conti 2014). In 2019, a federal appeals court threw out a lower court decision to halt construction of the Keystone XL Pipeline, potentially opening the door for jump-starting construction of the pipeline’s northern leg from Alberta to Nebraska (Banerjee 2019). In 2021, President Biden revoked the permit for the pipeline on his first day in office, and TC Energy announced in June it was canceling the controversial project (Denchak 2021). With the Keystone XL Pipeline, there are many examples of how individuals and groups interact in relation to special interest groups and political and economic reasons. When using the sociological perspective, it does not matter whether you are Democrat or Republican, believe or disbelieve that humans are causing climate change, or are for or against the Keystone XL Pipeline. What matters is understanding how individuals and groups interact within society, which will help you be a more informed and discerning citizen about complex issues such as the economy, politics, and climate change. Next, we will step back from the above micro views and examine economics and politics from a macro and structural perspective.
Economic and Political Structures
Economics and politics are structurally intertwined in many ways. This module will provide an overview of the types of economic and government systems and power structures. A theme you will notice in this module is the discussion of how power is structurally embedded within economic and political systems and the entities that hold this power. In an ideal society, every citizen would have equal opportunities within an economic system, and the political system would work to ensure equality for everyone. Each society approaches these ideas in different ways, resulting in different outcomes for its citizens. The economic systems and types of governments are explained first to provide the structural framework in which various entities leverage power.
A quick history lesson about types of societies is in order to describe the historical and economic changes before discussing the contemporary economic and political systems. The following, based on the American sociologist Gerhard Lenski’s work (1970), describes the different types of societies:
- Hunting and Gathering: hunting, fishing, and gathering of plants (e.g., a small number of Aboriginal people in Australia primarily still hunt and gather).
- Horticultural and Pastoral: basic farming and domestication of animals (e.g., farming by hand and nomadic sheepherders).
- Agricultural: large-scale farming with animals and machinery (e.g., animals used to pull plows).
- Industrial: manufacturing of goods using advanced sources of power (e.g., factories during the Industrial Revolution in the late 18th century).
- Post Industrial or Information Age: production of information via computers and emphasis on services rather than manufacturing (e.g., computer, news, and social media companies such as Apple, Microsoft, Yahoo, and Facebook).
Lenski described the first four types of societies, but the last category developed after his initial writings. Within the agricultural societies, small cities and feudal systems developed. It was not until the Industrial Revolution that large cities, industrial tycoons, and strong centralized governments emerged. What is important about the evolution of societies is that today’s economies and governments have only been present for a fraction of history and are now socially stratified. Individuals, groups, organizations, politicians, and corporations have gained tremendous power in the past 250 years, impacting economic and political landscapes. The two predominant economic systems, frameworks for producing and allocating goods and services within a society, are capitalism and socialism.
Economic Systems
Capitalism, an economic and political system based on private control of the production and distribution of goods and services within a free market system (HP), is the economic system that developed due to the Industrial Revolution in Western Europe in the 1700s. The U.S., Germany, Japan, Brazil, and Russia are examples of countries that employ capitalism as their main economic system. All the countries within the European Union (EU) are considered capitalistic economic systems.
Factories were built in England and operated freely without undue government intervention. The industrialists who owned the factories rapidly grew wealthy as a result of the free enterprise system, which was labeled laissez-faire capitalism, a system of free enterprise without government intervention. The French term means “to leave alone” or “let it be,” so the factory owners could control the production of goods and services within the free market, which fueled the economy’s growth. This new economic system led to 19th-century industrialists receiving enormous profits and gathering wealth. The derogatory term “robber baron” was coined in the 1870s to describe American industrialists like Andrew Carnegie and Cornelius Vanderbilt, who were accused of gaining their wealth through exploitative practices. In a 1907 Atlantic Monthly article, Charles Dole blamed the business magnates for the following:
- paying low wages
- exerting control over national resources
- creating monopolies
- receiving high levels of government influence
the last claim of receiving political favors and government concessions indicates how the melding of economics and politics had already become a structural element in society. The politically well-connected robber barons influenced laws and regulations that eventually led to monopolies, possessing near or complete control of commodities or producing goods and services (C-19). Oil baron John D. Rockefeller (photo) built Standard Oil Company and gained a 90 percent share of the oil refining business by 1880. In the same era, Cornelius Vanderbilt maintained monopolies in shipping and railroad transportation.
The second economic system is socialism, an economic and political system based on cooperative management or citizens’ production and distribution of goods and services normally within a democratic government (HP). The most common form of socialism today is seen within the context of social democracy. This is a system that leaves the means of production in private hands (rather than the government) but assures that regulations, some public control of the economy, and extensive entitlements exist to keep everybody at an adequate standard of living. Examples of entitlements include free health insurance, access to free higher education, and retirement support. Democratic socialist countries include Denmark, Finland, Netherlands, Canada, Sweden, Norway, Ireland, New Zealand, and Belgium. In socialism, production is designed to meet individuals’ needs and the collective good; this contrasts with capitalism’s focus on individualism and profits.
Socialism is often confused with a specific form of socialism — communism, an economic and political system based on the government’s ownership and regulation of all of the production and distribution of goods and services (HP). The last major communist regimes, East Germany and the Union of Soviet Socialist Republic (USSR), ceased to exist in 1989 and 1991, respectively. China, North Korea, Laos, Cuba, and Vietnam are the only countries remaining with communism as the basis of their economic system. Of these five, China is not a pure communist system. It still has a pre-capitalist agrarian system coupled with a socialist market economy. As Figure 11.2.1 shows, China now has the third-highest number of individuals having net assets greater than $1 million (MGM Research 2019).

Based on the exponential increase of millionaires in China, you can quickly deduce that China’s economic system is not the old communist system that existed in East Germany and the USSR. In 2023, a consulting firm predicts that 13,500 Chinese millionaires will relocate to other countries (Gordon 2023). The most cited reasons were to seek better educational and employment opportunities for their children and economic security for themselves. The Chinese borders are wide open, and nearly anyone requesting a passport will receive one. This emigration policy is in dire contrast to the communist countries of the past.
East Germany and the USSR were communist countries that were considered both communist and totalitarian, a state-controlled government holding all authority over public and private lives (C-19). Cuba is a totalitarian government controlled by General Raul Castro, as is Kim Jong-un’s North Korean totalitarian regime, which has been accused of severe oppression and systematic human rights violations. Twentieth-century communism was associated with totalitarianism and exploitation, far from the basic tenets that Karl Marx penned in The Communist Manifesto. Not all totalitarian governments are communist-ruled, as characteristics include single-party dictatorships that promote nationalism and silence opposition by law or violence. These governments control not only politics but also society’s social, cultural, and economic aspects. Recent events in Ukraine by the Russian military suggest that Russia may again be moving toward totalitarianism. After 70 years of communist rule, the Russian people seem to prefer President Vladimir Putin’s strong authoritarian style to a weak government and potential economic chaos.
Governing Systems
Although Russia is now a democracy, a system of government in which the power is vested in the people, and free elections are held, the rise of Putin’s political authoritarianism has been characterized as a “managed democracy” (Beer 2009). Other authoritarian governments include Iran, Venezuela, Azerbaijan, and Myanmar.
Myanmar (previously named Burma — see photo) is an example of a government that was an absolute monarchy, a system of government ruled by a monarch who has control of the government and state, in the 1800s, before being colonized by Britain. Examples of monarchs are kings, queens, emperors, princes, and princesses. Most monarchies today are constitutional monarchies, a system of government in which a monarch is the Head of State and is governed by a parliament (C-19). The Scandinavian countries of Norway, Sweden, and Denmark are examples. Others include the Bahamas, Japan, Morocco, Belize, the United Kingdom, and New Zealand, where the monarchs primarily serve as their country’s figureheads. The monarchies’ political and societal power has significantly declined in most countries over the past several centuries.
Models of Power
There are three models of power, the ability to exert control over others and achieve goals with or without the support of society, that describe systems of economic and political power. The Marxist power model, ruling forces formulate public policies that are in the best interest of capitalism and the ruling class, is a classic conflict theory perspective. The government especially favors economic policies that benefit the upper and corporate classes. It can be argued that U.S. politicians are comprised of members of the upper and corporate classes and the policies and laws they legislate are designed to protect and reproduce their power (HP). This model does not fully consider the non-economic political bases of economic power in societies such as unions, special interest groups, and religious organizations.
The power elite model, power is concentrated among the elite and wealthy, particularly corporations, government, and the military, derives its name from sociologist C. Wright Mills’ book of the same title (Mills 1956). This economic elite and policy-planning network of powerful individuals holds most of the power and is independent of the state’s democratic election process. Average citizens are unable to gain or exert significant power within the system since it is heavily controlled and weighted toward the elite. This model’s weakness is its oversimplification of the masses and the elites, as there are different classes and degrees of power held by individuals and groups. Citizens necessarily do not neatly fit into just the masses or elite categories. In an extreme form, a dictatorship, a form of government in which a single person or political entity controls political authority, monopolizes the majority of power. President Alexander Lukashenko rules the former Soviet Union country Belarus, considered Europe’s last dictatorship. He has been accused of rigging elections, neutralizing the parliament, imprisoning rivals, and censoring the press (Rugman 2014; Dynko 2012). Over the past several years, more than 2,000 citizens have been detained for opposition activities, which is one tactic Lukashenko has used to maintain his 20-year rule of the 10 million people in Belarus. His dictatorship of Belarus does not receive the media attention of North Korea’s Kim Jong-un. Do you expect dictatorships to continue throughout the 21st century?
The pluralist power model, power is fragmented and dispersed among groups within a society, consists of groups such as social classes, special interest groups, political groups, and many others. Each group provides checks and balances that result in a more even distribution of power. Public policies are negotiated between the groups, and the government serves as a neutral negotiator. The pluralist model represents how power is shared, negotiated, and distributed within social countries such as Norway, Sweden, and Denmark. This is an overly optimistic view of power, especially in the context of the United States. There is an over-reliance on the ability of competition and nontraditional interest groups to distribute power evenly. Often, it is the traditional special interest groups, especially political action committees (PACs), that are capable of creating power differentials within politics, which will be discussed in detail next.
Social Problems in Politics
The right to participate in the political process has been waged for generations. Whether it was women’s suffrage in 1920 or the end to legal discrimination against minority voters in 1965, many groups in American society have pushed for the right to vote. The early 21st century again saw the issue of voting take center stage with increased calls to require that voters meet certain legal requirements. While some believed this would work to refine the voting process, others saw it as a tactic designed to restrict political access to segments of the population. The most notable examples of social problems in the voting process involve the following:
- redistricting
- early voting restrictions
- college student voting
- voter fraud/voter ID laws
These examples qualify as attempts by those in charge to control some aspects of the political process. Let us begin by considering the efforts of some to creatively outline which voters are allowed to vote for which politicians.
Redistricting
The election of political leaders in the United States is based on a system in which states draw electoral boundaries known as districts. Voters within districts are only allowed to vote on certain political candidates that will represent that district’s interests. Residents living in Block 1 vote for candidates running for office in Block 1. Block-1 voters cannot vote for politicians representing Block 3 and so on. Redistricting, changes in the boundaries of an electoral voting district, sometimes called gerrymandering, has been viewed as a social problem. In some instances, the district lines have been redrawn to favor one political party’s interests over another at the voters’ expense. Due to redistricting, voters living in the same county might not have the option to vote for the same congressional representatives. Using the previous block analogy, when electoral districts are redrawn, some residents in Block 1 vote for one candidate, while their next-door neighbor might vote for a different candidate altogether. One of the most egregious examples of redistricting involved Illinois’ Congressional District 4, redrawn for the 2012 election. The goal was to allow the district to revert to the Democrats, which was successful as the one-term Republican incumbent Bobby Schilling was defeated by Democratic opponent Cheri Bustos in the 2012 election cycle. Figure 11.3.1 illustrates how this district was divided into two distinct halves connected by a thin strip of land along Interstate 294.
Illinois is not the only state that has been accused of creative districting, and examples can be found across the country. Another implication of this process is that certain racial, ethnic, economic, and religious groups in society are divided to reduce the power of their group vote. Returning to our hypothetical block analogy, we find that Hispanic-American voters are the majority in Block 1, and they are interested in voting for candidate M because they feel she will best represent their interests. After redistricting, the Hispanic Americans in Block 1 have been divided into four districts. Some residents can vote for Candidate M, but others cannot vote for her because they are no longer in her voting district. The other three-fourths of the voters on Block 1 have been reassigned to districts 9, 10, or 11, none of which have Candidate M on the ballot. Even though the Hispanic-American voters all live in Block 1 and are the majority, redistricting has weakened the power of their vote and reduced the chances of getting Candidate M into office. The redistricting process occurs every 10 years and is timed to coincide with the release of the latest U.S. Census Bureau figures on demographics for the nation. The most recent redistricting occurred in 2022, as it takes several years for the U.S. Census data to be processed and analyzed. Thus, this is why the Illinois district was redrawn in 2012. Once district lines are drawn, voters may have little chance of redressing the issue before the next redistricting cycle a decade later.
The electoral process in the U.S. is based on a “winner-takes-all” system. With this approach, the candidate who gets the majority of the votes in an election wins. Returning to our voters in Block 1, we find that if Candidate G gets 51 percent of the vote, Candidate G controls the whole district, even though 49 percent of the voters actually voted for Candidate M. Many people view the “winner-takes-all” approach to government as a social problem because of the potential for no representation for significant segments of the population. An alternative to the “winner-take-all” model is proportional representation, a system in which a political party’s representation in government is proportional to the number of votes they receive. Countries with proportional representation include Switzerland, New Zealand, Estonia, Denmark, Ireland, Sweden, Iceland, Finland, Netherlands, and Luxembourg (Ridley-Castle 2023). Based on this approach, 51 percent of the government seats would go to Candidate G, and the other 49 percent would go to Candidate M, resulting in a more accurate representation of the voting public’s will. Redistricting has both supporters and detractors and for that reason, it can be categorized as a social problem. Next, let us take a moment to consider when people are allowed to vote.
Early Voting Restrictions
On September 29, 2014, the U.S. Supreme Court restricted early voting in Ohio. In doing so, the court sided with a Republican-led effort to limit the number of days available to constituents to vote before an actual election. This 5 to 4 ruling was issued a mere 16 hours before early voting was set to begin (Barnes 2014b; Denniston 2014). Hover your mouse over the images below to learn more about issues associated with early voting and restrictions below.
Early voting is when the electorate can cast their ballots in person before election day. By comparison, absentee voting is when voters have their election ballots mailed to them.
Approximately 75 percent of states allow early in-person voting and voting by mail. Fifteen states require an excuse to vote by mail. Five states do not allow early in-person voting (IBEW Media Center 2018).
In 2000, 15 percent of voters went to the polls early, and that number grew to 40 percent in 2018 (Misra 2019; Block 2012). For the 2020 election, 150 million people voted early. That represents 65 percent of the eligible voting population (Kirby and Molla 2020).
Early voting reduces the need to stand in long lines and helps the electorate vote conveniently. Early voting may increase the percentage of low-income voters, as they do not have to take off work, although 23 states require employers to give employees paid time off to vote in general elections (Huddleston 2022).
Republican-controlled legislatures have worked to restrict early voting, and Democrats prefer expansion. When surveyed, 70 percent of Americans favor allowing voters to cast their ballot by mail (Pew Research Center 2018).
While states with Democratic-led legislators have worked to expand early voting, Republican legislatures in various states have passed laws restricting early voting. In 2021, 17 Republican states enacted laws to tighten the rules around casting ballots and running elections. Examples of restrictions include the following:
- shortening the number of days early voters can cast their ballot
- eliminating the same-day registration and voting option
- restricting early voting to weekdays and prohibiting evening voting
- allowing voting only in election offices and not neighborhood polling stations
- adding early voting to white suburbs while simultaneously cutting it in minority inner cities
(Viebeck 2021; Stern 2017; Lieb 2014)
Arguably the young, minorities, and low-income individuals are disproportionately impacted by restrictions to early voting. These groups typically have less flexible work schedules and can’t always get off work to cast their ballots during designated times during the week. Voters who encounter too many hurdles are more likely to become discouraged about voting and less likely to participate in the political process. As a college student, have you thought about whether you might experience voting restrictions? We will explore this issue in the next section.
College Student Voters
Of the subgroups that make up the American electorate, college students are in an unusual position. Many students go to college out of state. For nine months of the year, they reside in the town of their college, yet they may identify their home state as their true residence. Should they vote in their college town or in their home state? American college students who choose to vote have increasingly experienced a variety of restrictions in regard to participating in the political process. While some advocate restrictions as a way to maintain the integrity of elections, others argue that restrictions work to limit student access. Let’s take a moment to identify the range of changes college student voters have encountered.Legally and historically, students have had the right to register and to vote wherever they consider home. Yet, in 2011, state legislatures began imposing residency restrictions specifically aimed at college students. One such example was the New Hampshire House Bill 176 (HB176). This piece of legislation would have required students to maintain their original home as their place of residence even if they were unsure whether they would move back home after graduation (Doubleday 2011). While the New Hampshire House of Representatives voted down HB 176, this was not the only example of voting challenges encountered by college students.
For eight years, students at North Carolina’s Appalachian State University were allowed to vote early in the campus student union. Beginning in 2012, various rules were put in place by the local board of elections that made it increasingly difficult for students to vote (Walker-Wells 2014). These rules resulted in the “on campus” polling station being moved from the campus union to first a nightclub and eventually a location a mile from campus. The casual observer might argue that these changes were politically motivated. College students at Appalachian State University lean toward the Democratic party, consisting of 40 percent of the county voters and 35 percent of early voters. On the other hand, the board of elections was led by a Republican majority. A state judge ruled that the restrictions placed on the students by the board of elections qualified as disenfranchisement, an effort to restrict or revoke the voting rights of an individual or group. Discrimination against voters is nothing new and has included a variety of tactics that sound preposterous to our modern sensibilities. Hover your mouse over the images to learn more.
Voter Identification Laws
Should a person be required to present identification to vote? While this seems like a very straightforward question on the surface, the answer is fraught with pitfalls you may not have considered. Before 2006, showing photo identification was not necessary to vote in the United States (Lee 2012). In 2023, 35 states had laws requesting or requiring voters to show some form of identification at the polls (National Conference of State Legislatures 2023). Those in favor of voter ID laws say they are designed to reduce the likelihood of fraud in the electoral process by requiring voters to present some form of government-issued photo identification before voting at a polling station. Yet, research indicates that what little voter fraud exists takes place via mail-in ballots, not face-to-face at polling stations where photo identification is required (Childress 2014).
The larger question emerges: How do laws impact the voting public?