?
Feedback

Connecting Sociology and YOU!

Chapter 10: Race and Ethnicity

Notes:

 

Social Construction of Race and Ethnicity

Jodi Girard grew up knowing she had slightly different features than her White parents and sister. Jodi had curly hair and darker skin. In 2018, at 45, she took an Ancestry.com DNA test and learned her biological father is Black (Ridley 2022). Having identified as White her entire life, she now feels she does not fully belong to either race. This is an example of how our social environment and personal interpretations are primary forces in determining our racial identity. Next, we will discuss how race and ethnicity, two distinct terms that are sometimes mistakenly used interchangeably, are socially constructed.

Race

You may have already noticed the use of the terms “white” and “black” to describe Jodi’s concepts of race, a socially constructed category of people based on real or perceived physical differences. Physical differences refer to a person’s appearance, including skin, eye and hair color, and bone/jaw structure.

The definition of race varies by time and location, and an individual’s race is not necessarily easily identifiable based on physical appearance. Jodi’s physical appearance led her and others to perceive she was White. Individuals are most often categorized by their skin color. However, it is difficult to determine an individual’s race merely from physical characteristics. Broad categories such as “red, brown, yellow, black and white” (colors describing races from the popular children’s song, “Jesus Loves the Little Children”) have been used to define races. You may be bi-racial or have friends who have parents of two different races (i.e., White/Black, White/Asian), which creates ambiguities in categorizing a person’s race. Which of the three individuals in the photos is Hispanic or Latino American? Hover your mouse over the images to find out.

Bruno Mars (pop star): Mars was raised in Hawaii. His father is half Puerto Rican and half Jewish, and his mother is Filipino. He states, “There are a lot of people who have this mixed background that are in this gray zone. A lot of people think, ‘This is awesome. You’re in this gray zone, so you can pass for whatever the hell you want.’ But it’s not like that at all.”

Meghan Markle (Duchess of Sussex): Her mother is African American, and her father is Dutch-Irish. She states, “While my mixed heritage may have created a grey area surrounding my self-identification, keeping me with a foot on both sides of the fence, I have come to embrace that.”

Dwayne Johnson (actor, producer, and retired professional wrestler): His mother is of Samoan descent, and his father is of Black Nova Scotian descent. In a tweet, he states, “I identify as exactly what I am – both. Equally proud. Black/Samoan.”

Historically, the U.S. Census Bureau has experienced similar difficulties in categorizing and identifying races and ethnicities, periodically creating new categories and definitions. Beginning in 1790 to the present, the U.S. Census has used various categories to describe race. Blacks have been described as Slaves, Colored, Negro, Mulatto, Black, and African American. The 1790 U.S. Census included the following categories:

  • Free White males age 16 and upward (including Head of Household)
  • Free White males under 16
  • Free White females (including Head of Household)
  • All other free persons, except Indians, not taxed
  • Slaves

The “All other free persons” category included free blacks, taxed Native Americans, and all other people.

Currently, there are six categories describing Asian races and one “Other Asian” category. In 1900, the only Asian categories were Chinese and Japanese. The U.S. Census has excluded and added races and has used a variety of descriptions to categorize races over the two hundred years it has been conducted. It is to be expected there will be additional changes, even from decade to decade, as the concepts of race evolve. What’s clear is that race has been defined differently over time, is socially constructed, and is not necessarily easily identifiable based on physical appearance.

Ethnicity

The term race is often used with the term ethnicity, as in race and ethnicity. Ethnicity, social and cultural characteristics that set apart one group of people from another, is a way to group people based upon common heritage, language, food, and values. For example, the largest ethnic group in the U.S. is German American (17 percent of the population), followed by African American, English, Irish, Mexican, and Italian-Americans (Sawe 2017). We will discuss ethnicity in more detail later, so let’s first discuss how race is socially constructed.

Can you identify Irish Americans’ social and cultural characteristics other than those associated with St. Patrick’s Day? How are Mexican Americans categorized? Like most Americans, the U.S. Census uses the terms Hispanic and Latino interchangeably. Another term often used is Chicano. This term has various meanings, but most often, it refers to individuals born in the U.S. whose parents were born in Mexico. The 2020 U.S. Census addressed ethnicity in reference to being of Hispanic, Latino, or Spanish origin, the heritage, nationality group, lineage, or country of birth of the person or their ancestors before their arrival in the United States. Technically, Hispanics and Latinos are two distinct groups based on differences in language and origin. Hispanics and Latinos are racially and ethnically diverse, referring to a region of origin rather than a specific race. Hispanics originated from Spanish-ruled countries and speak Spanish, such as Mexico, Puerto Rico, Cuba, Spanish-speaking countries of Central or South America, and other Spanish cultures. Latinos refer to people of Latin American origin who do not speak Spanish in countries such as Brazil, Suriname, and Guyana. Americans of Hispanic or Latino origin may be of any race, and most identified as “White” or “some other race” in the 2020 U.S. Census. One of seven respondents identified as “Some other race,” boosting the category to become the country’s second-largest racial group after “White.” Many respondents easily identified their Hispanic origin but were stumped by the “Race” questions. With such a large “Some other race” category, there is concern this obscures the racial identity of many Americans, and they will not be represented accordingly (Wang 2021). Discussion is underway to consider additional ways of creating categories and wording race and ethnicity questions for the 2030 Census.

 

Stereotypes and Prejudices

An individual’s choice of associating with a specific race or ethnic group is often related to both positive and negative opinions held by various members of a society about such a group, which we will explore next.

 

Stereotypes

We form opinions about individuals, groups, races, and ethnicities based on our exposure to them. This results in the formation of stereotypes, generalized opinions, and impressions of individuals, groups, or social classes (HP). Stereotypes are assumed characteristics of other people that are not always accurate. Common stereotypes include intelligent Asians, athletic Black people, and the inability of White people to dance. This tendency lumps everyone in a race into one category and misrepresents the group.

Think about the last Halloween party you attended. Were people wearing any costumes that reinforced stereotypes? If so, this is an example of cultural appropriation, when members of a majority group adopt cultural elements of a minority group in stereotypical, exploitative, or disrespectful ways, associated with Halloween costumes. In 2016, a college party at an Illinois university sparked controversy over a Spring Break themed party due to partygoers wearing culturally-themed apparel, including traditional Arab keffiyehs, a Mexican sombrero, and a Native American headdress. Several student activist groups argued the party was culturally insensitive as the partygoers wore offensive, stereotypical costumes of marginalized cultures in society (Castillo 2016).

More than a decade ago, a campaign was created at Ohio University with the phrase, “We’re a Culture, Not a Costume.” The goal was to provide education and awareness about the cultural appropriation of costumes. This phrase has developed into a national campaign, and many colleges and universities seek to educate students to think critically about their costume choices. The DEI office of St. Lawrence University helps students understand the difference between cultural appropriation and cultural appreciation, defined as “[s]omeone seeks to understand and learn about another culture in an effort to broaden their perspective and connect with others cross-culturally” (St. Lawrence College 2022).

Is choosing a costume for a college party becoming more difficult? Do students have to consider race and ethnicity issues such as stereotyping? Three sociologists collected participant observation journals from 663 undergraduate students across the U.S. concerning racial events. Many students recorded their observations about costumes observed at college Halloween parties. An African American student who shopped late for a costume recorded the following

I asked an employee to help me out. He points me to the section with costumes for pimps and playas. So I said, “Are these the only costumes available?” He says, “You wouldn’t want the other ones, man, they’re really dorky, stupid, White people costumes, you need something cool, after all, Black dudes don’t wear no bullshit like that.” Now, the employee is White, and I’m laughing to myself, thinking, “Wow, I guess Black people have to maintain a certain level of stereotyped ‘coolness’ no matter what the occasion is.”

Researchers call this cross-racial costuming. Students believe that Halloween provides an opportunity to “play” with racialized concepts that makes fun of other races in a “safe” context. These actions often trivialize and reproduce racial stereotypes while supporting the racial hierarchy (Mueller, Dirks, and Picca 2007). Have you seen someone dressed up as an Indian for Halloween? What assumptions did you make about the costume and the image the person was depicting?

Native American Indians have been wrongly stereotyped and characterized as violent savages and warriors, largely due to depictions in television shows, movies, and documentaries. Many sports teams have mascots related to Indians, including the Atlanta Braves and the Chicago Blackhawks. The NFL Washington Redskins dropped “Redskins” and the logo, and now are the Washington Commanders. Over the past decade, many high school and college teams have changed mascots to be more culturally sensitive. In 2012, the Oregon Board of Education banned the use of Native American mascots in schools across the state (Kost 2012).

As a whole, Native Americans are viewed as economically deprived. This is an accurate perception based on the 2019 median household income of American Indians and Alaska Natives, which was $49,906, compared to $71,664 for the general population (Office of Minority Health 2021). Native American Indians have been socially marginalized and stereotyped as lazy, alcoholics, and warriors. These stereotypes are reinforced in a variety of ways and are difficult to change.

Stereotype Threat

One means of unintentionally reinforcing stereotypes is stereotype threat, a concern experienced when one feels at risk of confirming the inferiority or negative characteristics of one’s group (HP). This concern can result in performance-disruptive apprehension and impact academic achievement and athletic performance (Aronson et al. 2002; Stone et al. 1999). In essence, worrying about living up to the expectations of the stereotype can lead to perpetuating the stereotype. The stereotype threat can be applied to many different races and ethnicities. When the stereotype threat is internalized, and general stereotypes are perpetuated in society, it leads to patterns of thought and views of racial and ethnic groups. These types of racial stereotypes often lead to prejudiced attitudes.

Prejudice

Racial prejudice, a preconceived judgment or opinion of other people and races that leads to preferring one kind of person over another (HP), typically arises from race-based stereotypes. Prejudices are learned the same way other values are acquired, from association, reinforcement, and modeling during socialization. A child may learn from parents and peers to associate low intelligence, crime, and violence with specific races and ethnic groups. These stereotypes are reinforced through television shows, movies, and ethnic jokes. Consequently, the child may unconsciously imitate these prejudices. When presented with an opportunity to play with another child of a different race or ethnic group, the child may shun the potential playmate based on adverse preconceived judgments and opinions. Ultimately, these judgments and opinions may lead to discrimination.

Discrimination

Exposure to prejudices can cause children and adults to learn to prefer one race over another. This can lead to discrimination, unfair or differential treatment of individuals and groups. Since there are laws against racial discrimination, this type of treatment tends to be subtle rather than overt, as in the case of a person not being hired or promoted due to race. For some, their experience of discrimination is multifaceted and includes actions taken by others against them because of intersecting factors, such as ability, class, gender identity, race, sex, and sexual orientation. This intersectionality means that a person often experiences disadvantages because of multiple factors.

Redlining

 

People can face racial discrimination when moving into a segregated neighborhood or applying for a home loan. Banks and other institutions have engaged in redlining, the practice of arbitrarily denying, limiting, or charging more for financial services, insurance, or access to healthcare to specific neighborhoods, based on racial and economic issues. In the 1960s, a sociologist coined the phrase to refer to banks mapping red lines around neighborhoods, specifically those with populations of poor White or Black families, to indicate that those living in these areas were unsuitable recipients of home loans. It was common practice for banks and insurance companies to use racial criteria to categorize lending and insurance risks and show a preference for one group of people over others (Zenou and Boccard 2000; Holmes and Horvitz 1994; Barth, Cordes, and Yezer 1979). The economic notion of redlining is based on prejudice and ultimately leads to discrimination.

The low-income sections of this 1936 map of Philadelphia are in red. Under redlining, the households in these areas could not get mortgages or business loans. Today there are many regulations designed to prohibit or limit the practice of redlining. However, it is difficult to distinguish the impact of racial discrimination from the effects of the more generalized factors considered in obtaining a loan, insurance, or healthcare coverage. In this case, discrimination occurs when the individual lender treats the potential borrower differently because of prejudicial attitudes about neighborhood location. Research indicates that a majority of neighborhoods marked “hazardous” in red ink on maps drawn by the federal Home Owners’ Loan Corp. from 1935 to 1939 are today much more likely than other areas to comprise lower-income, minority residents (National Community Reinvestment Coalition 2018). Even 80 years later, the lingering effects of redlining are apparent, with the pattern of economic and racial residential segregation still evident in many U.S. cities. Evidence, such as the 2018 exposé of redlining practices in 61 cities, a 2015 study stating redlining is alive and well and evolving, and a 2010 national analysis of redlining in seven cities, demonstrates redlining still exists, although the discrimination is subtler by mortgage lenders (Glantz and Hernandez 2018; Mock 2015; White 2012). It is still evident that people of color are far more likely to be turned down for a home loan than their White counterparts, even though policies and organizations are addressing the issues of redlining and redevelopment.

The 1977 Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) requires banks to make loans in all neighborhoods they serve, not just the wealthy neighborhoods. The Justice Department has a 20-person unit dedicated to overseeing unfair lending practices, thus demonstrating the practice of redlining has not been eliminated. In 2022, the California Association of Realtors, the Minneapolis Area Realtors, the St. Louis Realtors, and many other real estate industry groups publicly apologized for historical racist practices. In St. Louis, an initiative has been developed to reckon with its past and build a more equitable future (KMOV Staff 2022). Existing laws and policies must be enforced, and new policies and programs must be developed to protect and improve the lives of the disadvantaged (Benson 2011). One redevelopment program in North Carolina has successfully addressed the needs of low-income communities.

In recent years, the nation’s economic challenges hit the Black community particularly hard. In light of the recession, foreclosures, and layoffs, difficult decisions were made about public spending and cuts that impacted low-income neighborhoods and communities. Redevelopment funding for these impoverished areas was limited during the recession. To address this issue, the North Carolina Community Economic Development Initiative and its network of partners provided $3 million in grants in 2011 to replace the blight and neglect with green, sustainable neighborhoods and businesses. The grants were targeted to promote energy-efficient sustainable buildings and strengthen area communities and families, which are predominantly Black. The initiative has significantly impacted low-resource communities by promoting the green economy, sustainable development, job creation, and leadership development in North Carolina. Since the initiative’s inception, there have been $78 million in capital investments, and 50,000 citizens have become homeowners and learned financial skills (NC Community Development Initiative 2019; Frantz 2012). Job creation is critical for this initiative’s success, but discrimination can be evident throughout the workplace, from hiring practices, promotions, and layoffs.

Workplace Discrimination

 
 The Civil Rights Act of 1964, specifically Title VII, strictly prohibits all forms of discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin in all aspects of employment. During the interview process for your first job out of college, you may be hired or not hired based on your race, color, or national origin. This form of discrimination is difficult to detect. Other forms of racial discrimination in the workplace involve the following situations:
  • racial jokes or humor that is demeaning or insulting to minority groups
  • systematic failure to promote qualified members of minority groups
  • specific minority groups receiving lower pay raises than Whites or other minority groups

The above situations may be difficult to manage in large corporations, as individual managers are often given autonomy in hiring and promotion decisions. Another form of discrimination is microaggressions, words, and deeds that negatively impact marginalized individuals, groups, or communities. Dr. Onyeka Otugo, a Black physician, states she is often mistaken as a custodial or food service worker when she enters a patient’s room, even after introducing herself as a physician (Goldberg 2020). Another example is meeting a new friend and telling them, “You don’t look Jewish,” when they tell you their ethnicity. Not all forms of discrimination are subtle or can be viewed as gray areas, as in the case of racism.

 

Racism

Racism, the belief that one race is superior to others resulting in unequal or demoralizing treatment of other races (C-19), can be easier to identify than discrimination. Historical examples include American slavery, the Holocaust, and apartheid in South Africa. A 2017 poll asked how big a threat is racism to society today. Thirty-six percent stated it is an “imminent threat to the country,” and 42 percent stated it was a moderate or serious threat to the nation’s stability (Whitesides 2017). The definition of racism includes “unequal or demoralizing treatment,” and Figure 10.1.1 describes how Blacks and Whites differ in their views on whether Blacks are treated less fairly than Whites in various situations.

Blacks consistently report feeling treated less fairly than Whites in each of the seven situations. As discussed previously, redlining still exists today in a much subtler form, and this survey supports this claim, as 74 percent of Blacks stated there is unfair treatment “When applying for a loan or mortgage.” Only 38 percent of Whites felt Blacks are treated less fairly in this situation. This is evidence that Whites and Blacks have different views on how these situations impact each race. Due to the recent highly publicized events involving Blacks and law enforcement, there seems to be more agreement that Blacks receive unfair treatment involving the police and the criminal justice system.

An ongoing national conversation about racism emerged and continued largely due to the 2012 shooting death of 17-year-old African American Trayvon Martin in Florida by George Zimmerman, a White neighborhood watch volunteer who was found not guilty by a jury; the 2014 shooting of an unarmed Black teenager, Michael Brown, in Ferguson, Missouri, by a White police officer; and the murder of nine African American worshippers at the historically Black Emanuel A.M.E. Church in Charleston, South Carolina, by Dylann Roof, a 21-year-old White male. These incidents established and bolstered Black Lives Matter, an activist movement that campaigns against violence toward Black people. Michael Brown’s death by a White police officer and the resulting grand jury declining to indict the officer led to racially charged protests and riots across the country. Immediately after the shooting of the parishioners in Charleston, a Facebook photo circulated of Dylann Roof with the Confederate flag in the background. Roof’s self-proclaimed racially motivated hate crime was linked to the Confederate flag’s historical and contemporary symbolism that led to the removal of the flag from the South Carolina State House. In 2014, Eric Garner was detained and choked by an NYC officer. Garner said, “I can’t breathe,” 11 times during the arrest and died due to the altercation. In 2019, the U.S. Department of Justice ruled it would not bring federal charges against the NYC police officer, which enraged many Americans. As mentioned in Chapter 7, George Floyd’s death in 2020 resulted in the conviction and sentencing of a White police officer, Derek Chauvin, and is hailed a civil rights victory. These incidents have raised the question of the extent of institutional racism, societal patterns that produce negative treatment against groups of people based on their race. Specifically questioned is racism in law enforcement, the criminal justice system, state and federal government, and society in general. Although issues of racism against Blacks have garnered the most recent national attention, Hispanics and other groups experience similar treatment.

Despite federal and Supreme Court challenges, Hispanics face racism with anti-illegal immigration laws and anti-sanctuary city laws passed in states such as Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, Georgia, Indiana, Iowa, South Carolina, Texas, and Utah. The debates center around the legality of checking the status of people suspected of being in the country illegally, requiring employers to verify workers’ immigration status, and sanctuary cities where local agencies are barred from aiding federal immigration enforcement (Gomez 2019; Hayoun 2019).

Due to the amount of revenue high-profile sports teams generate and the high salaries of sports celebrities, teams and athletes are protected and insulated from discrimination and racism.

This is a myth.

It can be difficult to discuss racism due to the topic’s emotionally and politically charged nature. One approach is avoiding the topic altogether, as, in the case of racial colorblindness, the idea that ignoring or overlooking racial and ethnic differences promotes racial harmony (HP). This belief focuses on treating people equally, which will lead to a more equal society, and that privilege due to race no longer exercises the same power as in the past. Individuals ascribing to this belief espouse individual choice and equal opportunity and oppose legislation to reduce inequality. In essence, racism is falsely overlooked in favor of believing that racial problems will cease to exist if we all just get along.

A nearly opposite perspective to racial colorblindness is when individuals recognize that racism exists but intentionally attribute the racism to other nonracist factors, thus perpetuating the causes of racism. An example of this approach is stating that poverty among Latinos is not due to racism but caused by the ethnic group’s lack of work ethic, ignoring the existing inequalities and discrimination. Another example is viewing residential segregation simply due to the natural tendencies among minority groups to want to live with people of the same color and background. This ideology is based on the following beliefs:

  • The U.S. society serves as a racial meritocracy (each race is judged on its own merits and achievements and not on its skin color).
  • Most people don’t care or even notice race.
  • Any racialized patterns of social inequality that persist are outcomes of individual or group-level cultural deficiency or both.
  • Because of the above beliefs, no systematic measures (such as affirmative action) must be implemented to redress racial and ethnic social problems.

(Bonilla-Silva 2014; Krysan and Lewis 2004)

Attempting to hide the existence of racism can be an intentional means of perpetuating it. While some individuals hide or ignore racism, others simply don’t realize they exhibit racist characteristics.

Some individuals overtly display racist attitudes and behaviors but may not realize or accept being characterized as being racist. This is often the case with prejudicial attitudes and discriminatory behaviors derived from the socialization process in the family, among peers, and even in the media. It is unrealistic to think stereotypes, prejudice, discrimination, and racism can be eliminated in society, but it is possible to strive to reduce each. One way to do this is to emphasize the importance and benefits of accepting and respecting individuals and groups of a different color, race, or national origin by emphasizing the value of diversity.

Race and Diversity

A more positive outlook on race and ethnicity focuses on diversity, the recognition and respect of the different attributes of races and ethnicities (HP). Rather than concentrating on the negative aspects of what divides people, diversity focuses on the positives, such as each race’s rich cultural characteristics. You personally benefit from having a racially diverse campus that respects differences among all students. Socializing and discussing racial issues with classmates of different racial and ethnic backgrounds contributes to the following:

  • academic development and a higher GPA
  • overall satisfaction with college
  • increased level of cultural awareness
  • commitment to promoting racial understanding
  • intellectual and social self-confidence

Colleges and universities realize that to be successful and recruit and retain the best students, they must value their students’ diversity (HP). Organizations and corporations also recognize the importance of valuing the diversity of employees and the clients they serve, especially when operating in global markets.

With globalization increasing our contact with people from around the world, it is important to strive toward an emphasis on pluralism, maintaining social equality and distinct cultural characteristics within and among races and ethnicities. Pluralism represents the affirmation and acceptance of diversity. A key component of pluralism is for races and ethnicities to maintain their distinct cultural characteristics, in contrast to assimilation, the process in which minority groups lose their distinct cultural characteristics and are absorbed into the dominant group. Irish and Polish immigrants to the U.S. experienced ethnic discrimination upon their arrival in North America, which motivated them to assimilate into the American culture. Immigrants often changed their last names to hide their ethnicity and adjusted their clothing and diet. Today, it is difficult to distinguish who is Irish or Polish. In contrast, pluralism celebrates the unique language, customs, and beliefs of different races and ethnic groups.

Assimilation and pluralism are at the heart of the European refugee crisis. This crisis significantly impacts many European countries that initially extended an open-door policy to refugees from the fallout of the Arab Spring, the civil war in Syria, and sub-Saharan Africa. In general, these economic migrants and political refugees have settled in European countries and have not integrated into the cultures. Scandinavian countries such as Norway, Denmark, and Sweden, lean more toward desiring refugees to assimilate, which requires them to learn the language, find employment, pay taxes, and eat Nordic food. In contrast, the refugees have moved to ethnic enclaves in large cities and have not learned the language, and are more likely to be unemployed and dependent on the government to sustain them. By 2019, these circumstances created conflict and a crisis, as nationals want refugees to adapt and contribute or are hinting at rolling up the welcome mat. Let’s examine an example of how Korean immigrants have combined assimilation and pluralism on migrating to the U.S.

Korean American history provides a mixture of the concepts of assimilation and pluralism. In 2010, Koreans comprised 10 percent of the Asian American population, and 63 percent still had close family living in Korea (Cohn and Wang 2013). The Korean American sociologist Won Moo Hurh (2000) identifies four types of patterns experienced by Korean immigrants:

  • Traditionalists: High degree of ethnic consciousness, live in Korean enclaves, and speak only Korean.
  • Integrationists: Detached from the Korean community and attempt to live as White Americans.
  • Isolationists: Unable to live as Korean or American in the U.S. and return to Korea.
  • Pluralists: Limited social assimilation, preferring to identify as Korean and American.

The Korean traditionalists and isolationists choose not to assimilate, while the integrationists fully assimilate. The pluralists choose to maintain a balance between the two cultures. It is important to keep in mind that one pattern is not inherently better or worse than the others. By respecting the importance of diversity among Koreans, we are utilizing the sociological perspective.

Have you ever thought about your racial or ethnic identity concerning assimilation or pluralism? Can you identify stereotypes or prejudices you hold against other races? Have you experienced discrimination or privilege because of membership in a particular race or ethnic group? By incorporating the sociological perspective, you will better understand yourself and be better equipped to have more meaningful and informed conversations about topics related to race and ethnicity. At times, these conversations may be uncomfortable as you question your own beliefs and the beliefs of others, but ultimately tackling these complex and sometimes controversial issues can be a positive growth experience.

 

Structural Categories

Stereotypes, prejudices, discrimination, and racism lead to social patterns that are institutionalized over time and provide the foundation for social structures. In the U.S. and many other countries, race-based privileges have become institutionalized, resulting in a powerful social structure. This section will address racial and ethnic groups, privileges based on race, and how race and ethnicity impact institutions such as the family, education, health care, and the structural impact of media on racial and ethnic groups. People are commonly grouped into two structural categories regarding race and ethnicity — majority and minority groups. In most societies, members of one group enjoy social, political, and economic benefits and advantages.

Majority Groups

The dominant or majority group, a group that controls the economic, social, and political power and resources, is often, but not always, the group largest in population. In the U.S., the majority group is White Caucasians, with economic and political dominance. Politically, the majority of politicians are White males, which serves to maintain dominance by the majority group. Figure 10.2.1 shows that in the 118th U.S. Congress, 75 percent of the members are White, although Whites comprise only 59 percent of the U.S. population. Despite this, the 118th U.S. Congress is the most racially and ethnically diverse in history, with 116 lawmakers being non-White (Schaeffer 2023; U.S Census 2023).

In 2022, the U.S. Census reported 59 percent of Americans were White, 18.5 percent were of Hispanic or Latin origin, 13.4 percent were Black, 6 percent were Asian, and 1.6 percent were American Indian/Alaskan Native/Native Hawaiian/Other Pacific Islander (U.S. Census 2022). Not long ago, many Americans could not envision the day a Black president could be elected, while many today cannot envision a racially representative U.S. Congress. Since the election of President Obama, there has been hope that the latter can also be accomplished. As you will see next, for nearly 50 years, many South Africans could not envision a nation/state not ruled by Whites.

In most cases, the majority group is the largest, but one exception was the rule of Whites in South Africa from 1948–1994. Although the Whites were a minority in number, Whites controlled the law and ruled the government. This system of racial inequality consisted of laws segregating Whites, Blacks, Colored, and Indians to maintain White dominance and institutional racism. Whites in South Africa represented only 20 percent of the population but controlled the nation/state economically, socially, and politically. In South Africa, the disadvantaged Blacks, Colored, and Indians represented the second category — minority groups.

Minority Groups

A minority group, a disadvantaged group with significantly less economic, social, and political power and resources, represents subordinate groups such as Hispanic, Black, Asian, American Indian, Alaska Native, and Native Hawaiian/Other Pacific Islander. Specific characteristics common among minority groups include physical, cultural, and language traits that differ from the majority group. Many minorities, but not all, have lower educational attainment, poorer health outcomes, and shorter life expectancies due to low socioeconomic status (SES). Contributing factors include inferior schools, obesity, and lack of access to health care. Membership within a minority group is involuntary, and often inequalities and conflicts exist between the majority and minority groups.

Historically, conflicts between the majority and minority groups in the U.S. are often studied and discussed in relation to the removal of Native Americans from their native lands, the enslavement of Black Americans, the incarceration of Japanese Americans in prison camps during World War II, and the economic exploitation of Hispanics. Less attention has been given to conflicts between and within minority groups in the U.S. For example, Latinos often hold negative views of Black Americans, and a survey found that half of the Black Americans and half of the Korean respondents reported they did not get along very well. Large cities such as New York, Dallas, and Los Angeles have had a history of riots, boycotts, and violence between Black Americans and Koreans since the 1990s (Black News 2013; Park 1996). Minorities are becoming a greater percentage of the U.S. population, which may change the social dynamics between the majority and minority groups and between minority groups.

An interesting trend occurred in the U.S. in 2011. For the first time, more than half of newborn babies were minorities (Cauchon and Overberg 2012). Today, minorities comprise 42 percent of the U.S. population, and by 2045, the U.S. is projected to become majority-minority, when a population or district consists of over 50 percent minorities (U.S. Census Bureau 2015; 2021). Hispanics are becoming a majority-minority in many cities in the U.S. Seven of the 15 most populated U.S. cities were comprised of majority-minority people of color in 2012, including Los Angeles and New York, the two most populous cities. In 2022, five states had a population that was less than 50 percent White; Hawaii, California, New Mexico, Nevada, and Texas (U.S. Census 2022). It is estimated that by 2060, minorities will account for the majority of residents in 22 states and will make up two-thirds of the total U.S. population (Maciag 2015). In 2015, 50.3 percent of children younger than five living in the U.S. were minorities (Cohn 2016). These facts and projections are examples of the changing demographics of minority groups, which will also bring economic, social, and political changes. But despite these changes, the majority-White population will continue to maintain privilege and power within the U.S. into the foreseeable future.

White Privilege 

The structural benefits of white privilege, an invisible package of unearned assets held by Whites (HP), are evident in the U.S. McIntosh (1988) described this privilege as similar to an “invisible weightless knapsack of special provisions, maps, passports, codebooks, visas, clothes, tools, and blank checks.” McIntosh listed 50 daily effects she received as a result of her white privilege, of which four are listed below:

  • I can, if I wish, arrange to be in the company of people of my race most of the time.
  • I can go shopping alone, pretty well assured that I will not be followed or harassed.
  • I will feel welcomed and “normal” in the usual walks of public life, institutional and social.
  • Whether I use checks, credit cards, or cash, I can count on my skin color not to work against the appearance of financial reliability.

Although the above examples seem obvious, many White males do not readily understand white privilege, as it is easily taken for granted or falsely considered an earned advantage (Greason 2012; Wise 2007; McIntosh 1988). Sociologist W. E. B. Du Bois termed this privilege as the unearned “wages of whiteness” (Du Bois 1935).

Why might it be difficult for White males to view acts of racism against minority groups as providing an advantage to the dominant group? To a White person, whiteness is considered normal; to a minority group member, whiteness looks like all the benefits they never expect to receive (Greason 2012). Structurally, white privilege provides material, social, and psychological benefits, although many Whites are not fully aware of the inherent advantages of their whiteness. As discussed next, a reality show confronted white privilege and racism, which led to a national conversation on the topics.

As discussed next, white privilege can be seen in the 2020 incident in which Christian Cooper (Black American) was bird watching in NYC Central Park and politely asked Amy Cooper (White and no relation) to leash her dog to comply with park rules. She declined to leash her, dialed 911, and said, “I’m going to tell them there’s an African American man threatening my life.” Mr. Cooper used his phone to video the incident, which went viral. Fordham University professor Bryan Massingale states that Ms. Cooper may have acted based on assuming her white privilege would reinforce her cultural assumptions that “white people matter, or should matter, more than people of color.” Massingale provides specific examples of potential assumptions of white privilege pertaining to this incident:

  • She assumed he, the black man, would have a presumption of guilt.
  • She assumed her lies would be more credible than his truth.
  • She assumed if he protested his innocence against her, he would be seen as “playing the race card.”
  • She assumed he knew any confrontation with the police would not go well for him.
  • She assumed Christian Cooper could and would understand all of the above.

(Massingale 2020)

These are merely assumptions, as we do not know what Ms. Cooper was thinking. These assumptions can undergird the ways of whiteness and how it works in society. This type of white privilege is embedded in society, and often it is not easily recognized. As a result of her behavior, Ms. Cooper was fired from her job and had to return her dog to the pet adoption agency.

Whether it is an encounter in a park or some other mundane social interaction, race and ethnicity can be pivotal factors. Next, we will examine how issues relating to race and ethnicity impact other areas of your life, such as family, education, and health care.

 

 

 

Institutional Patterns

Race and ethnicity affect family structures, access to education and healthcare, and media representation. We will examine each of the issues in more detail, beginning with snapshots of the structural differences between the four largest race and ethnic categories.

Family Characteristics

Structural CharacteristicsAsianBlackHispanicWhite% of Population3% – 10 million12% –
40 million18% –
60 million61% –
201 millionMatriarchal (M)
Patriarchal (P)
PMPPBirths to Unmarried Mothers11.8%69.4%52.1%28.4%Median Household Income$83,376$40,324$51,389$69,851Percent of Inter-marriage29%18%27%11%Poverty Rate10.0%21.2%18.3%8.7%

Asians have fewer births to unmarried mothers and the highest annual household income and percent of inter-marriage. Whites have the lowest poverty rate, and Blacks have the highest. The annual household income for Asians is twice the income of Blacks. The percentage of births to unmarried mothers for Blacks is six times higher than for Asians. These statistics provide a glimpse of the structural differences between the races that have remained relatively constant for decades.

The infographic to the left is a compilation of statistics from the U.S. Census Bureau (National Fatherhood Initiative 2017), displaying the increased risks of being raised in a father-absent home. Additional statistics that shed light on structural differences indicate an estimated 44 percent of Black fathers do not live with their children. By comparison, 21 percent of White and 35 percent of Hispanic fathers don’t live with their kids (Livingston and Parker 2011). Not living with their father does not mean the father is absent from their children’s lives. For children under five, 13 percent of non-residential Black fathers bathed, diapered, and dressed their children daily. Seven percent of non-residential White and Hispanic fathers engaged in similar behavior. When it comes to playtime, the CDC reports that 17 percent of Black, 7 percent of Whites, and 10 percent of Hispanic non-residential fathers play with their children daily (Jones et al. 2013). While these statistics highlight the parental engagement of non-residential fathers, the broader family experience is often overshadowed by the reality of poverty. Black and Hispanic families have the lowest annual household incomes due to low educational attainment, single-parent family households, and in some cases, undocumented status. These unique cultural and structural differences between families help provide insight into why inequalities persist between the races. While Asian Americans, Hispanics, and Whites predominantly have patriarchal families, Black families are matriarchal due to nearly 75% of births among Black families being to unmarried mothers and fathers being absent.

Education

Some of the economic disparities found across racial categories can be traced to differences in the quality of schools and access to higher education, as you will read next.

The three most significant educational issues of race are the historical and current-day racial segregation, the separation of groups based on differences such as ethnicity, gender, race, social class or religion (HP), desegregation, the elimination of the policy of segregation by legal and social means, and affirmative action, policies designed to promote educational and job opportunities for minorities and women, in higher education. The American school system has been legally desegregated since the 1954 Supreme Court ruling of Brown v. Board of Education, but de facto segregation, segregation that happens “by fact,” rather than a requirement, remains. In other words, even though there are laws prohibiting segregation, it still exists structurally in the educational system, communities, and prisons.

New York has the most segregated schools in the U.S., followed by California, Texas, and New Jersey (Lockhart 2019). In 2016, 40 percent of all Black students and 41.6 percent of all Hispanic students were in schools with 90 percent or more students of color. White students attend schools in which 69 percent of the students are White compared to Hispanic students attending schools in which 55 percent of the students are Hispanic (UCLA Civil Rights Project 2019). Structurally, segregation is a characteristic of the American educational system and can lead to disadvantages to students due to having less qualified teachers, a lack of up-to-date technology in the classroom, and fewer opportunities for cultural and educational extracurricular school activities. In 2006, parents from the Chicago suburb of Elgin filed a class-action racial bias discrimination lawsuit stating that the school system was shortchanging Black and Hispanic children in segregated schools. In 2013, the court ruled that the school district’s gifted program indeed discriminated against minority students. This lawsuit demonstrates an attempt to right the wrongs within the educational system (Walberg 2013).

Health Care

There are significant structural disparities between Whites and minority healthcare coverage rates, which result in unmet medical needs and worse medical outcomes. Lower incomes and higher rates of poverty are examples of structural barriers that impact minorities. In 2017, the uninsured rate for Hispanics was 16.1 percent, compared to 10.6 percent for Blacks, 7.3 percent for Asians, and 6.3 percent for Whites (U.S. Census Bureau 2018b). Life expectancies will vary by race and ethnicity due to access, affordability, and quality of health care. In 2017, the life expectancy of Blacks was 75.3 years, compared to Whites at 78.8 years, Hispanics at 81.8, and Asians at 86.67 (National Vital Statistics Report 2019). An explanation for why the life expectancy for Hispanics is greater than Whites will be provided in Chapter 14. In relation to the COVID-19 pandemic, the life expectancy of a White man dropped by eight-tenths of a year during the first six months of 2020, while a Black man’s life expectancy was shortened by three years. Prior to the pandemic, the difference in life expectancy between Black and White men was three years; therefore, there is now a three-year difference in their life expectancies due to communities of color suffering disproportionately throughout the pandemic (Santhanam 2021).

Overall, your race and ethnicity may impact your family’s characteristics, quality of education, healthcare coverage, and even how long you will live. Let’s shift our focus to how media impacts how you view the different races and ethnic groups that you read about above.

 

Structural Impact of Media

Media is a powerful force in forming images and shaping beliefs about majority and minority groups in the U.S. Have you considered how media reinforces stereotypes of ethnic groups?

The Asian American stereotype of the model (or ideal) minority group, an ethnic group that is more academically, economically, and socially successful than other racial minority groups, is widely held in the U.S. The stereotype is based on the perception that Asian American students are more successful than other racial minority groups because of an intrinsic value of hard work and parents who push them to exceed. The stereotype is based on the perception that Asian Americans are more successful than other racial minority groups because of their work ethic, respect for elders, and high evaluation of education, family, and elders in their cultures (Chang 2002). This label one-dimensionalizes Asian Americans and does not represent the numerous other qualities and characteristics evident among this diverse population

.In reality, many ethnic groups comprise the term “Asian Americans” and there are just as many students at the bottom as at the top of the educational ladder. This group is represented by Chinese, Filipino, Indian, Vietnamese, Koreans, Japanese, Cambodians, Taiwanese, Hmong, Samoans, Bengalis, Sri Lankans, and many others (Lewin 2008). Asian Americans consist of 45 distinct ethnicities that speak 100 dialects (Hing 2012). Chinese Americans represent 85 percent of the Asian-American population, approximately 20 million of the total U.S. population of 329 million (U.S. Census Bureau 2019). Fifty percent of individuals in the top six Asian-American ethnic groups graduate from college, compared to 30 percent for the general population. Their median annual household income is approximately $20,000 more than the median for Americans (U.S. Census Bureau 2018a). These numbers support the model minority stereotype but do not consider all Asian Americans.

For instance, Chinese and Vietnamese Americans have lower attainment of high school diplomas, and more than one-third of all Hmong, Cambodian, and Laotian Americans over 25 do not graduate from high school (Lee et al. 2016). Keep in mind that many Asian Americans live with extended families (more family members and thus more wage earners living in the same home), and this will increase the household income, which may skew the median annual household income. It is accurate to say that some Asian Americans fit the stereotype of the model minority, but we can’t lump all Asian Americans into the same category. These stereotypes can lead to high expectations for Asian American students. Students who don’t meet the group’s expectations may be alienated or excluded from the minority group. This can lead to low self-esteem, depression, and even suicidal thoughts. It is difficult to escape these stereotypical characteristics of the model minority as the media reinforces them daily.

Latinos have been negatively portrayed through stereotypes or largely ignored on television, movies, animated cartoons, and news. They are more often depicted in roles as Mexican bandits, gangsters, drug dealers, and prostitutes, in contrast to being successful and exhibiting prosocial behavior (Picker and Sun 2012; Klein and Shiffman 2006). A content analysis of Latino characters on prime-time television concluded that Latinos were portrayed less positively than others regarding physical attractiveness, dress quality, personality characteristics, and importance to storylines (Harwood and Anderson 2002). Latinos and Asian Americans are significantly underrepresented on cable news shows such as CNN, Fox News, and MSNBC (Savillo and Willis 2013).

Media plays a key role in constructing your view of differentraces and ethnicities through stereotypes and reoccurring images. In print media, the dominant beauty standards are filtered and reinforced based on specific racial characteristics. In “White-oriented magazines,” Black women are often featured with lighter skin tones, straightened hair, and a generally less curvy figure. In contrast, “Black-oriented magazines” portray Black women with medium complexions and curvy figures (Hazell and Clarke 2008). In 2012, Beyoncé was voted People magazine’s Most Beautiful Woman, contributing to societal views of the qualities of beauty regarding Black women. Consider specific examples of how the media impacts individual views of ideal beauty concerning various races and ethnicities. The media influences your ideals of beauty, beliefs about victimization at the hands of racial minorities, sexual attitudes, moral judgments, and racial identity development (Mastro et al. 2009; Eyal and Kunkel 2008; Martin 2008).

Significant differences and inequalities exist among racial categories within the family, education, and health care. Media reinforces negative stereotypes of minorities, perpetuating prejudices, discrimination, and racism in societies. These distinctive and stable arrangements of social patterns related to race and ethnicity form social structures embedded within society.